Midway, Kentucky

The pizza looked old. It was room temperature, which is Not rare at this location, when it arrived. When my toddler spit it out, I tried it and no wonder he spit it out. It tasted Like Dirt & Old.

The cheese was slimy & tepid. Mushroom had a grainy texture with dirt taste. The pizza was made sloppy and carelessly. I Bet it was dropped or something nasty.

I am filing a complaint with the FDA. It was absolutely nasty and also it was a free pizza with the 25 point catch. Figures.

You can see from the photos that the cheese has a sheen. But, don't let that fool you. It's not cheesy goodness, it is a slimy, phlegmy substance. The sauce also looks as if it was sitting overnight on the dough. Yuck.

Disgusted Consumer

Review #397258 is a subjective opinion of a user.

Not specified
Reason of Review / Monetary Loss Not specified / Not specified
Preferred solution Not specified

Had an Experience with Papa Johns Pizza?

Submit review


Comment as anonymous or
Terms of Service
Post Comment
San Jose, California, United States #825444
I got a pizza from Papa Johns and get this it had a big load of human excrement on it as a topping.
Lakeland, Florida, United States #631865
That really makes you wonder what your eating anymore.. :x
Joe Smoe
Papa Johns is a Greedy *** Republican, and dont really care how good your pizza is, just wants your $$$
to Joe Smoe Coos Bay, Oregon, United States #832458
Everybody wants money. His being a Republican has nothing to do with his greed. Plenty of losers are Democrats, too.
Lititz, Pennsylvania, United States #631657
You should contact the store directly and let them know you weren't satisfied. The FDA has nothing to do with a situation like this. You would have to contact your local Health Dept if you think someone has unsafe food practices. On the side of the box it says 100% satisfaction. If contacting the store directly doesn't work then submit a complaint through their website. Based on your photos they didn't make it correctly regardless of the freshness. The crust is all blown out and the toppings slid toward the middle. I would have to say it was made by a new trainee anyone else should be ashamed.

You May Also Like

"I ordered 3 boneless buffalo combos on Wednesday, 3/2/16. My daughters and I sat down to eat and after eating about 3 or 4 wings we discovered that the chicken..." Read more
"The pizza was terrible and flavorless. The cheese was not even fully melted. ..." Read more
"I happen to be under the common impression that Subway is healthy and hygienic. I was frequently the boat basin outlet (Karachi, Pakistan) that is open 24/7 on a regular..." Read more
"Um do you check your rice before you import for cheap??? Do you have QC checking this stuff? I just bought a box on Saturday of hamburger helper crunchy..." Read more
"Give your head a shake Nascar. you had a winner in 2001. NOW THIS STAGE STUFF. i'M A 74 YEAR OLD WHO LIVED FOR THE BRICKYARD TILL THAT WENT DOWN..." Read more
"I spent $80 on a fruit basket for my daughter and what arrived looked nothing like the picture. The basket was pathetic and the amount of fruit came no where..." Read more
"I went thru the enrollment process, wanting to be insured for 2016. Unfortunately, because of my financial situation, I was unable to make my first or any other premium payment..." Read more
"We Make it Easy!- A delusional motto Cast: Mike- Super intendent of Construction for William Ryan Keith- Realtor preferred by William Ryan Lisa/Tiffany- Sales Representatives for William Ryan Ernie/ Ben-..." Read more