The pizza looked old. It was room temperature, which is Not rare at this location, when it arrived. When my toddler spit it out, I tried it and no wonder he spit it out. It tasted Like Dirt & Old.
The cheese was slimy & tepid. Mushroom had a grainy texture with dirt taste. The pizza was made sloppy and carelessly. I Bet it was dropped or something nasty.
I am filing a complaint with the FDA. It was absolutely nasty and also it was a free pizza with the 25 point catch. Figures.
You can see from the photos that the cheese has a sheen. But, don't let that fool you. It's not cheesy goodness, it is a slimy, phlegmy substance. The sauce also looks as if it was sitting overnight on the dough. Yuck.
Review about: Papa Johns Pizza Pizza.